Two window cleaners in harnesses and white hard hats suspended by ropes against a glass building facade

Whitepaper · Feb 2026 · 19 pages

The average mis-hire costs 15 times their salary. Here's the fix.

The Vitr CLEAR Hiring Framework: Topgrading distilled for Australian SMEs. Roughly 80% of the benefit at 25% of the time (our estimate).

Back to all thinking

Summary

In 2014, Myer hired a Group General Manager on a package worth around $400,000. Within a week he was fired. The CV was fabricated, the referees were fake, and he had already done the same thing to at least five other Australian organisations. Ten minutes of phone calls per referee would have caught him. Nobody made them.

The Flanagan story is extreme, but the process that let him through is how most Australian SMEs hire: a CV scan, a friendly chat and an outsourced reference check. This whitepaper turns Topgrading, the hiring method developed by industrial psychologist Bradford Smart, into a five-step framework a small business can use. It takes around five to seven hours of focused work per senior hire. Topgrading estimates the average mis-hire costs 15 times the person's salary.

What's inside

The real cost of a mis-hire: Topgrading puts it at 5 to 27 times annual salary, and the biggest losses never show up on an invoice.
What an A-player actually is, and why you don't need to outbid competitors to hire one.
The CLEAR framework: five steps that, in our estimate, capture around 80% of full Topgrading in a quarter of the time.
The "threat of reference check": one sentence, said early in the process, that makes candidates more candid.
Scripts for candidate-arranged reference calls, plus the seven questions to ask when you get the manager on the phone.
The 90-day onboarding loop, and the 5% pay rise test that tells you whether to make the offer at all.

Related thinking

Tool · July 2026 · 4 min

Would your leadership team score your culture the same way you do?

Most leaders find out their culture has drifted only after it shows up in turnover and the numbers. Our free five-minute Culture Health Check helps you see it sooner.

Whitepaper · Oct 2025 · 18 pages

Why half your employees can't name your values

A practitioner's framework for writing purpose, vision and values that hold under pressure, drawn from work inside real leadership teams.

Field note · July 2026 · 4 min

The gun hire

The revenue promise was real. So was the risk. A field note on the hardest kind of hiring call, and what rebuilding looks like when it goes the wrong way.